The ACB will return to regular posting on January 3, 2011. In the meantime, we head into this holiday season with a review of Take 6’s new holiday album, It’s the Most Wonderful Time of the Year.

Recording a holiday album is simultaneously one of the simplest and most confounding things any musical act can do. On one hand, holiday music easy. There’s a huge selection of songs to choose from, many of which already have multiple versions, and many of which are in the public domain. In addition, you know that you’re going to have willing listeners. Whereas groups may traditionally worry if they’re really reaching their audience, or if their song selection will be off-putting, Christmas has a built-in fan base of people eager to drink in what you’re putting out there.
On the other hand, holiday recordings are challenging because it’s difficult to accomplish something truly new, and you’re inevitably going to face comparisons with others who have tried their hands at the same tunes. As a result, it can actually be more difficult for a holiday album to receive a positive critical response, because there’s a lot more room for apples to apples comparisons.
Given the nature of holiday music, I have tendency to favor songs in this genre that provoke an emotion. Take Sarah McLachlan’s “Wintersong,” the title track of her 2006 holiday album which is positively haunting, tragic, and beautiful. Another example would be Bruce Springsteen’s version of “Santa Claus is Coming to Town,” on which the down home, rocking joy of the piece is so palpable that I can’t help but smile and think back to times when dreams of Santa seemed plausible. The long and short of it is that these are songs that will not get lost in the holiday shuffle—they’re provocative, grabbing and ultimately distinctive.
With all of that said, Take 6’s It’s the Most Wonderful Time of the Year is an interesting experiment. The group has openly stated that it means for the album to sound warm and familiar—to conjure up holiday memories, and to be easy to sing along to. On these notes, the album is, indeed, quite successful.
Where this album falls short is in its inability to stand out. The only approximation of an emotion this collection consistently drew forth for me was that of nostalgia. Otherwise, the album came across as too breezy, lightweight and generic for my tastes. I worry that the everyday listener could miss the a cappella nuance at play and readily mistaken the album for the easy-listening holiday favorites broadcasted at department stores across the country this time of year.